What’s The Best Electric Fireplace Insert To Buy In 2018 Reviewed

What do you think – what are the best electric fireplace inserts on the market? If you ask me, I would say that several models are worthy of customers’ attention. Why would you listen to me? Well, because I have a lot of experience with firebox inserts and I tested dozens and dozens of them over the years.

I will share with you the list of the top units available today, but we will not stop there. You will also learn how to pick the most appropriate hearth for your needs and how to install and take care of it properly. By the end of the article, you will become an expert on the topic. I believe that you can’t wait to start, so let’s not waste any more time!

9 Best Electric Fireplace Insert 2018 Review

1. PuraFlame 33" Western Electric Fireplace Insert with Remote Control

PuraFlame 33" Western Electric Fireplace Insert with Remote Control

Check More Photos & Price at: amazon.com

Let me give you several reasons why you should choose PuraFlame 33” Western Electric Fireplace Insert with Remote Control. For starters, its design will fit any room decor thanks to the black frame and the fantastic 3D flame effect.

The screen shows faux stone background, as well as an ember bed, logs, and fire that are incredibly lifelike. You can use the remote control for adjusting glow and intensity of the flame, as well as for regulating the heat level.

The temperature range varies from 60F to 84F, and there is a thermostat that keeps track of the current heat. The thermal overload protection will prevent the unit from overheating.

You can choose to turn off the heating altogether and just enjoy the beauty of the 3D flame screen. The measurements of the product are 35 x 27 x 8.8 inches, and it comes with a 1-year warranty on
 all components.

2. Dimplex DFI2309 Electric Fireplace Insert

Dimplex DFI2309 Electric Fireplace Insert

Check More Photos & Price at: amazon.com

The strength of the heater is somewhat lower than standard since it packs 1,375W of power. However, the maximum efficiency and forced fan secure warmth to up to 400 square feet of space around the unit.

Dimplex DFI2309 Electric Fireplace Insert has an incredibly realistic flame effect, with resin logs looking particularly beautiful.

The unit can be placed into the opening of your existing fireside as long as it can fit the dimensions of 25.5 x 21 x 13 inches.

The weight of the product is 34 pounds, and you shouldn’t have any issues installing it yourself. You can use the remote control to select the desired settings. That means you won’t have to get up from the sofa to turn the heating up or down. Aside from adjusting the brightness of the flame, you can select from three different heat settings – high, low, and fire only.

3. Comfort Glow ELCG251 Electric Log Insert, Heater & Firebox Projection 5,120 BTUs

Comfort Glow ELCG251 Electric Log Insert, Heater & Firebox Projection 5,120 BTUs

Check More Photos & Price at: amazon.com

The manufacturer of Comfort Glow ELCG251 Electric Log Insert went with an interesting approach when it comes to flame effect. They combined three colors – black, red, and orange, to portray a wood-burning fireplace.

The result is an ember bed that is glowing and a flame that is dancing on the screen, which looks incredibly appealing.

You can use the unit all year round because it doesn’t require you to turn on the heating if you don’t need it.

But if you do have a desire for warmth, you can utilize the 1,375W heater and heat up a medium-sized room. The entire unit is controlled remotely and from any part of the room or by using the panel on the side of the product. The expected settings are all there, including adjusting the heat level and the brightness of the screen. The dimensions of the unit are 20 x 12.3 x 8.8 inches.

4. BCP SKY1826 Embedded Fireplace Electric Insert

SKY1826 Embedded Fireplace Electric Insert

Check More Photos & Price at: amazon.com

Did you always want a fireplace, but you were afraid of safety risks? Electric firebox inserts are incredibly safe, and Best Choice Products SKY1826 Embedded Fireplace Insert has a couple of extra layers of safety.

They come in the form of CSA certificate and thermal overload protection. It is a built-in hearth that you can place anywhere and hardwire it (connect directly with your electrical wiring without the need for any cables lying around).

The unit packs a heater with 1,500W of power, but you don’t have to utilize all of it. In fact, you can use low heat settings (750W) or no heat at all. In that case, you will just enjoy the beautiful illusion of a flame on a screen with tempered glass. The flame look is soothing to the eye, and you can always adjust the glow to your taste with the remote control. You can use this unit as your electric wall mounted fireplace as well. One of the top rated and best electric fireplace inserts available today.

5. ClassicFlame 36EB110-GRT 36" Traditional Built-in Electric Fireplace Insert

ClassicFlame 36EB110-GRT 36" Traditional Built-in Electric Fireplace Insert

Check More Photos & Price at: amazon.com

Unlike some other fireboxes, I can’t say that the ClassicFlame 36EB110-GRT 36” Traditional Built-in Electric Fireplace Insert has a flame effect that looks overly realistic.

However, if you appreciate 3D technology, you will enjoy watching the dancing flames from all angles. There is also a contemporary version of this model, and it offers a flame screen that creates the illusion of burning gas.

This unit doesn’t excel regarding heating either. It has a 4,400 BTUs (1,375W) heater, which is modest compared to some other fireboxes. However, it is incredibly reliable and durable and can heat up a moderately-sized room.

You will even get a thermostat that shows the current temperature, and you can adjust the heat level from 60F to 90F. The remote control is also provided to make changing the settings to your taste even more comfortable. The dimensions of the unit are 36 x 24 x 7.6 inches.

6. AKDY 23" Black Freestanding Electric Firebox Fireplace Heater Insert

AKDY 23" Black Freestanding Electric Firebox Fireplace Heater Insert

Check More Photos & Price at: amazon.com

You might not have heard for this manufacturer, but you will be thrilled with this product. AKDY 23” Black Freestanding Electric Firebox Fireplace Heater Insert has everything you might expect from a hearth.

For starters, it has 22 different heat settings. The temperature range varies from 62F to 82F, and you are free to choose the warmth level to your preference. Of course, the remote control will make that job a whole lot easier.

The heater itself is 1,400W strong and is suitable for standard-sized rooms (up to 400 square feet). The black frame and the see-through tempered glass are a winning formula when it comes to design.

As for the flame screen, there might be room for progress, but as far as the faux fires go, it looks brilliant. It’s vital to note that you can mount the unit as a fireplace insert or as a freestanding firebox.

7. XtremepowerUS 28.5" 1500W 5200BTU Embedded Electric Fireplace Insert Heater

XtremepowerUS 28.5" 1500W 5200BTU Embedded Electric Fireplace Insert Heater

Check More Photos & Price at: amazon.com

One thing went through my mind when I tested the ExtremepowerUS 28.5” 1500W 5200BTU Embedded Electric Fireplace Insert. I couldn’t resist thinking that the flame looks beautiful with the resin logs and the adjustable glow of the fire.

But then I realized that this unit not only looks nice, but it has a considerable heating potential. The 1,500W of power and two different heat settings are more than enough for average-sized rooms in any house.

As an American product, this fireplace comes with UL certificate. That means all the equipment pieces and components can perform as stated in the details. But just in case, there is also the thermal overload protection to keep everyone safe. 

The installation of the unit shouldn’t be a problem. It is a simple process, and you can handle everything yourself since the firebox weighs only 20 pounds. Just keep in mind that the measurements of the product which are 28.5 x 21 x 6.75 inches.

Another good thing about this insert is you can place it into your electric fireplace TV stand box as well. This one is the most realistic electric fireplace insert to me among all.

8. Giantex 28.5" Electric Fireplace Insert with Heater Glass View Log Flame

Giantex 28.5" Electric Fireplace Insert with Heater Glass View Log Flame

Check More Photos & Price at: amazon.com

We will talk about maintaining your firebox a bit later, but let’s just say that the fact the tempered glass on the front is easily detachable will make your job effortless.

While we are talking about looks, let’s mention the visual appeal of the Giantex 28.5” Electric Fireplace Insert.

It looks incredibly attractive, and its compact design will make it fit for any room. The dimensions of the product are 28.5 x 21 x 5.7 inches.

The strength of the heater is 1,500W, but you don’t have to use the heating if it’s warm outside. Using the unit all year round and controlling it with the remote from anywhere in the room is an excellent combo.

You can choose between three hotness levels (no heat, low, and high modes), but you can also adjust the glow and intensity of the flame. In case something goes wrong, thermal overload and tipping overprotection are there to keep you safe.

9. Duraflame DFI021ARU Electric Log Set Heater with Realistic Ember Bed

Duraflame DFI021ARU Electric Log Set Heater with Realistic Ember Bed

Check More Photos & Price at: amazon.com

Are you tired of maintaining your wood-burning fireplace? Think about changing it with the Duraflame DFI021ARU Electric Log Set Heater.

You just need to insert this product into the existing opening and enjoy the beautiful dancing flame effect without the need to clean up or worry about venting correctly.

The unit comes with a 1,500W heating element, and it’s up to you to decide the desired temperature in the room. You can use the thermostat to adjust it. 

If the thermometer notices that something is wrong, it will utilize the thermal overload protection and automatically turn off the unit.

The remote control is an incredible and simple to use addition to this fireplace. Four buttons enable ultimate control – you can choose to turn the unit on or off, adjust the heat level and the brightness level of the flame.

How to Pick the Best Insert For Electric Fireplace

Electric firebox inserts have plenty of benefits regardless of the model you choose. They maximize energy efficiency while ensuring low running cost. On top of that, they are incredibly safe thanks to a bunch of safety features, such as no venting required. But how to choose the most suitable electric fireplace for your home? The answer is – by taking a look at this buying guide.

Choose the Appropriate Type

You can choose between two types of electric firebox inserts:

  • Electric log set fireplace inserts
  • Built-in fireplace inserts

Electric log set fireplace inserts are designed to substitute your existing gas or wood-burning hearths. If you get tired by a unit that takes a lot of time and effort for maintenance, electric log sets are a far more comfortable option. They use the existing opening you have on the wall and literally come in place of your previous firebox. 

The other kind is built in or plug-in electric fireplace inserts. The difference is that these come with a box that is enclosed and that has faux items, such as log beds, crystals, or glass inside. All this provides the flame effect and the illusion of a fire burning. Built-in fireplace inserts are also placed into an existing wall opening, and they only need to be plugged into an electrical socket to start working.

Choose the Right Location

Did you know you can use an electric hearth insert in virtually any room of the house? If you want to keep your bedroom warm, they can provide just that. And if you would like to improve the aesthetics of your living room, electric fireplace inserts are also an excellent choice. 

You need to select the location by the type of the hearth you desire. In fact, it might be even better to do it another way around. For example, if you have an existing wood-burning fireside, it’s only logical to substitute it with the electric log set fireplace insert. 

Make Sure That It Fits with the Room Decor

Take a look around your room. How it is decorated or how do you want to decorate it? The electric hearth insert you choose needs to fit with the overall style of the area around it. You need to make sure that both the color and design fit with the décor of the room. That is the only right way to utilize the aesthetics of these units to the max and make them a real focal point in any home.

How Much Heat Do You Need?

In general, you can select between two different types of heating – infrared and fan-forced. The majority of electric fireplace inserts use the second option. Most of the heaters provide up to 5,100 BTUs per hour of heat (1,500W of power).

That is enough for space of around 400 square feet, but it still depends on the model. Make sure that the unit is plugged into its own electrical socket because extension cords and electric fireboxes are a combination that can lead to blown fuses and possible fire outbreaks.

Electric Fireplace Insert Installation

Are you ready to install the electric fireplace insert instead of your existing hearth? Here we will have to assume that you’ve cleaned everything and that you have purchased the unit of the right size for the opening in your wall. 

Before installation, you need to take care of one more thing – see if the product works. This is just to be on the safe side to save you from a possible hassle of installing a non-working unit. Once you had plugged it into an outlet and tested that everything works, you can move on to the installation.

Step 1 – Cover the Chimney and Close the Damper

Is your chimney equipped with a rain cap? If the answer is no, you will need to place a cover plate on it. Make sure to secure it with silicone to ensure the water won’t come in and cause an issue with your new hearth.

Also, take a look at the damper of the firebox. You should close and seal it if you want the heating element of the electric insert to be maximally efficient. Otherwise, you risk losing a considerate portion of the heat through the damper or due to drafts.

Step 2 – Find the Source of Electricity

Electric fireplace inserts require an electrical socket. It’s crucial that you don’t use an extension cord because these products draw maximum power and need a dedicated circuit. You can use any power outlet nearby and just plug the firebox there.

Alternatively, you can also install a socket inside the fireside opening. This will prevent having cables lying around, and it’s more appealing visually. However, if you don’t have experience with electricity, I strongly suggest that you hire a professional electrician for this step.

Step 3 – Place the Fireplace in the Opening

There shouldn’t be any problems with this step. You just need to carefully slide the fireside insert into the opening you prepared for it. Next, make sure that it is centered and leveled. There might be some screws involved when it comes to leveling, but that depends on the model.

You might also have brackets that are used to connect the firebox to the back and the floor to ensure that the unit won’t get knocked over. Read what is listed in the instructions and follow the manual to make sure you did everything that was required.

Step 4 – Connect the Frame and Turn It On!

The final step is to place the frame or the trim. By doing this, you secure that there are no ugly-looking gaps between the opening and the wall. Once the structure is in place, you can plug in the insert and start enjoying your new fireplace!

Electric Fireplace Insert Maintenance

You won’t find a safer hearth alternative than using an best electric firebox insert. Aside from simple installation, the essential benefit is that maintaining these units also doesn’t require a lot of effort. However, here are some maintenance tips you need to keep in mind. Please note that each of these maintaining tips requires the unit to be turned off and unplugged from the outlet for your safety!

How to Change a Light Bulb

In general, the light bulbs that come with electric fireplace inserts are incredibly durable. However, they won’t last forever, and you might need to change one (or more) of them at some point. To change a bulb, you will need to access it first.

The general rule of thumb is that they are in the back, which is why it is a good idea to use the rear panel to access them. However, you might want to consult your product’s instruction to be sure.

Now that you have access to the light bulb, you should replace it with any other and return the rear panel in place.

Do You Need to Clean the Fan?

Although the fan of the firebox doesn’t require a lot of maintenance, you will need to check if it works correctly occasionally. The fan shouldn’t be dirty, louder than usual, or have problems with rotating. You can use a small vacuum or a cloth to remove any dust from the fan, but be gentle. I suggest cleaning the component at least once a month to extend its durability. 

Make Sure the Exterior Is Clean

Just like the fan, the outside part of your fireplace might also get dirty. That is why you should clean it on a regular basis. You can clean the tempered glass with a moist cloth and glass cleaner. Use a dry cloth to remove the dust. Before cleaning the exterior, make sure that the firebox has cooled down.

Final Thought

It’s not easy to find the best electric fireplace insert these days. However, I hope that this article managed to provide all the relevant information you need to choose a unit that suits your taste. You have the option to select one of nine firebox inserts that I believe are currently the best in this product category.

If you were worried about installing a fireplace, I’m sure you don’t worry anymore thanks to the installation guide provided. You even know how to maintain your unit once you purchase it. So, what are you waiting for? It’s time to buy the desired electric hearth insert and start enjoying its warmth and visual appeal!

Vernon Scott
 

Vernon is the founder of this cool ( read HOT! ) website. He's superbly experienced on heating technologies as well as having clear ideas about modern heating appliances. Vernon has called him " I am a hot ( this time read COOL! ) guy!"

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments